Testimonials & Reviews

Did you have a good experience with us?

Current Rating in Google: 4.9 of 5

Reviews brought to you by

Pat Sada

April 26, 2021

What an amazing store. Located in a historic building in Amherst Ohio, it is a hidden gem. All products, including Pandora and Brighton, in addition to other jewelry lines, purses, footwear, etc., are displayed very artfully. The store is very neat and orderly considering the vast selection of items stocked. The employees are very helpful, and greet you with considerable enthusiasm as you enter the premises. Definitely recommend this establishment as a go-to stop if you are looking for a unique item. I will be returning very soon!!

Jill McCullough

June 9, 2021

Shop has a lovely assortment of gift possibilities, including for oneself! Pleasant atmosphere and helpful friendly staff. I will be back. So fun to shop in a boutique!

barbra eaton

April 8, 2021

I have been going to the Mermaids Tale for many years. I love the old , vintage building that is beautifully maintained. The variety of merchandise is impressive, clothes, purses, many jewelry lines, and so much more. During these Covid times the protocols are being strictly enforced. During my visits, both Stacey and Wendy could not have been nicer, or more helpful.

Karen Shawver

May 6, 2021

Always friendly. Always a great selection of unique finds priced for every buyer! Thanks Judy and staff! You are appreciated.

Victoria Brian

January 17, 2021

Mermaid’s Tale is the best place to shop. Everyone is friendly and always willing to help. So many options for beautiful gifts. Gift wrapping is beautiful❣️There are so many ways to shop too! You can order by phone, do a virtual visit. Love this store♥️ I am a mermaid for life🧜‍♀️

Current Rating on Yelp: 4 of 5

Reviews brought to you by

Lauren S.


Three words: glam, girly, and gaudy. Three wonderful ways to describe a great store like this one. Stumbled in here during Dancing on Main Street, and...READ MORE

Mike S.


I have been so impressed with the staff here that I finally decided to rate them what I feel they deserve. I have purchased many gifts for my wife from...READ MORE